Soap & Glory 'Glow all Out' / Makeup Revolution 'Gold Lights' / theBalm 'Mary-Lou-Manizer' / MAC 'Soft & Gentle' / MAC 'Vanilla' Pigment / MAC Creme Colour Base 'Pearl' / NARS 'Albatross' / Illamasqua 'Furore' Pigment /
Here are a few (not really a few) highlighters I love to use. Some are more subtle than others such as the Soap & Glory 'Glow all Out' which is almost like a highlighter/blush combination, and others are a bit more extreme such as the Mary-Lou-Manizer, which is the most extreme highlighter I own. You could make any highlighter a bit more crazy and use a fixing spray on the brush you're using to apply it with, such as MAC Fix+ or for a cheaper alternative MUA now do a fixing spray which is pretty good.
If I want to go for something a bit in-between on the highlighter spectrum, I love to use NARS Albatross, which is a shimmery pearl shade with a hint of gold running through it, and if you want a cheaper 'dupe', then Makeup Revolution's 'Golden Lights' is very similar, it's slightly more golden than NARS Albatross though. For an all time classic MAC's Soft & Gentle just has to be included, it is probably my favourite highlighter as it can be worn both day and night and is just perfect in every way possible. It's a perfect highlighter if you're just getting into highlighting! Pigments can be gorgeous highlighters, and you don't need to use much product either, which is a bonus for your bank account. I love MAC Vanilla pigment which is great for highlighting the inner corners of my eyes to brighten them up a bit, if you want a more warmer highlighter then Illamasqua 'Furore' pigment is a gorgeous champagne perfect for all over the eyelids, inner corners and the cheekbones, it's pretty much an all-rounder!